445. A Compliment to England

Having watched 19 matches of the Rugby World Cup so far, it’s time to pay a compliment or two to England and the organisers.

  1. Nice weather
  2. Big crowds

The first is not something that is often, or often enough, said in relation to the English. But every match has been played in beautiful conditions. Sunny, dry, firm. Well done. (Of course, I have probably now put the mockers on what weather follows. Sorry.)

The second is something that must have worried the organisers. Would the local crowds turn out to watch matches that do not involve the home team?

The answer has been an emphatic “yes”, and that has contributed massively to the spectacle of the tournament. A game watched on television is enhanced by the size and enthusiasm of the crowd in the background. Compare that to the meagre crowds seen behind many of our Super XV and NPC matches.

My only quibble would be the sporadic ‘singing’ by those crowds of Swing Low, Sweet Chariot, the preferred song of England fans, even when England is not appearing. For why?

Why indeed is the song the choice of those fans in the first place?

It is, of course, an easy one to sing, in that it does not require much singing ability at its least. There are not many words to remember. Volume overcomes skill in a stadium or dressing room or bus setting.

But it is discomforting to hear a slave spiritual being appropriated to support a country with such a colonial past. It is the lyrical equivalent of parading the Elgin Marbles in front of Greeks, whether bearing gifts or not.

25431While it has been sung by many rugby teams for many years, it’s association with the English rugby team at Twickenham is very recent: 1988, when Chris Oti scored a hat-trick of tries against Ireland on debut. Recall that Oti is black, and you can choose whether to think it’s use was ironic or insulting or uplifting.

For an idea of how the song is meant as a plea for redemption from suffering, try this version by the late great Paul Robeson.




About Ned Davy

By hokey, the big fella’s tipped into his 50s. A rangy loose forward in his prime, good with the ball in hand, but rarely up with the play any more.
This entry was posted in Ned and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to 445. A Compliment to England

  1. rayinnz says:

    Good point, the more you think about it, the worse it is
    Off to Goggle to find out why the dumb Pom’s sing it anyway

  2. Jon Norman says:

    1. My wife would disagree with this statement
    2. The Olympics proved the English will turn up en masse whatever the sport. I just hope I live to see a football World Cup played here.

    I was watching highlights of England’s 1991/92 cricket tour of New Zealand (as you do) and was surprised to hear ‘Swing Low’ sung at various times by the English fans. I know not why as I have never heard it sung at a cricket ground.

Go on. Have your say.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s